Elon Musk's SpaceX Russia Trip: The Meeting That Started It All

The Elon Musk SpaceX Russia trip was meant to end with cheap rockets bought from Moscow. It ended with an insult, a failed negotiation and a decision to build his own instead.

In the summer of 2001, a phone rang in Logan, Utah, and a stranger introduced himself in one long, unpunctuated breath. He was Elon Musk. He had made his money at PayPal. And he needed Russian rockets, because he had decided humanity needed to become a multi-planetary species and this seemed like the fastest way to ignite the idea. The man on the other end, a rocket engineer named Jim Cantrell, had spent years buying decommissioned Soviet hardware at bazaars where launch systems sat next to stacking dolls. He was, improbably, exactly the right person to call.

The Elon Musk SpaceX Russia Trip Nobody Expected to Matter

Musk's actual goal that year had nothing to do with building a rocket company. He wanted to send a small robotic greenhouse to Mars, a project called Mars Oasis, and broadcast pictures of green shoots growing in red soil back to Earth. The idea was not primarily scientific. It was theatrical, in the best sense. A photograph the evening news could run in eight seconds, embarrassing enough about NASA's shrinking planetary budget that Congress might feel compelled to fix it. None of that required Musk to build anything himself. It just required a rocket cheap enough to make the stunt affordable, and in 2001 there was exactly one category of vehicle that fit: a decommissioned Soviet ICBM, sold off as part of post-Cold War disarmament.

Musk tried Europe first. He and two travelling companions, his college friend Adeo Ressi and Cantrell, went to Paris to see if Arianespace would sell him a launch. That went nowhere, priced well outside what a greenhouse mission could justify. So the group turned to Moscow instead, in October 2001, to meet the people who actually built the rockets Musk wanted.

A Trip to Moscow, and a Considerable Amount of Vodka

The meetings did not go the way Musk expected. Russian officials at NPO Lavochkin and Kosmotras treated the group, by most accounts, as tourists rather than customers. There was a great deal of vodka involved, toasted in twos and threes an hour, which is not obviously conducive to closing an arms deal. Cantrell has since described watching Musk pass out at the table before he did the same himself. Not the version of the SpaceX origin story that makes it into the marketing material.

The Russians, by Cantrell's account, treated the 30-year-old Musk as a novice with more money than credibility, and one of their chief designers reportedly showed his contempt by spitting near the visitors' feet. The group flew home without a rocket.

Why the Price Kept Rising Every Time Musk Went Back

A second trip followed in February 2002, this time with an extra passenger. Mike Griffin, who had worked at the CIA's venture capital arm and would later run NASA itself, came along to help Musk make sense of what was being offered. Each time they went back, the offer and the price changed. According to Cantrell, the Russians had originally discussed a price in the region of eight million dollars per rocket. By the second trip, the number had climbed to something closer to twenty million each, for three. Not exactly a loyalty discount. It put the whole plan well outside what Mars Oasis could justify on any budget Musk was prepared to spend.

The Spreadsheet That Ended Mars Oasis and Started SpaceX

What happened next is the part of the story SpaceX tells often, and the detail varies slightly with who is telling it, though the shape stays the same. On the flight home, Musk pulled out a laptop and started working through the actual cost of building a rocket from raw materials rather than buying one secondhand from a country that no longer particularly wanted to sell. According to early investor Steve Jurvetson, Musk calculated that the raw materials for a rocket amounted to roughly three percent of what a finished launch actually cost to buy. Aluminium, kerosene, liquid oxygen, electronics, labour. Add it all up and you are nowhere near the sticker price. Somebody, somewhere, was making an enormous margin on getting things into space, and it was not going to be the Russians anymore.

That gap is not really a story about Russian obstinance. It is a story about margin, and Musk seems to have understood almost immediately what it implied. If launch itself was the bottleneck holding back every space ambition he had, including his own greenhouse, then the rational move was not to keep shopping for a cheaper supplier. It was to remove the supplier from the equation entirely.

Musk founded SpaceX in June 2002, several months after that flight home, putting roughly a hundred million dollars of his own PayPal fortune behind it. Mars Oasis, the greenhouse that started the whole search, never flew. The rocket that would have carried it never got bought. What did get built, eventually, running through years of failure that very nearly ended the company on its own account, was Falcon 1. I still think there is something almost funny about how close humanity came to sending a plant to Mars instead of a company that builds its own rockets. The plant would have been a great stunt. But a stunt is all it would have been.

Frequently Asked Questions